Litamity Book Club
  • Home
  • The Books
  • Current Reads
  • The Club Blogs
  • Schedule
  • Forum
  • Contact

The Secret River, by Kate Grenville

CLARE has written this months review of our selected book.

It was great to have our first London Litamity meeting - only small with Lou W, Sarah and I, but lovely to be back in the old familiar feeling of discussion, "girl time", hearing each other's thoughts, and being challenged and extended as Book Club always does.  Our conversation initially centred on the violence towards the Aboriginals by the White Settlers.  While we had all studied the First Settlers and Convicts many times through school, I was never aware of the viciousness and maliciousness these attacks took - cutting the ears and hands off, poisoning the Aboriginals' flour with cyanide, and the final mass murder of the sleeping Aboriginal tribe.  It is a shameful part of our history but one that cannot be skimmed over or hidden away.  Our next question was - what we can do to make it better NOW?  And we found this very challenging, especially as - with and race - Aboriginals are made up of individuals who have individual needs and cannot be fixed with one solution.  For me, it was almost as if we can do more NOW for a crisis which is happening at the moment, say in Sudan, where I can send $100 and know this will make a difference, rather than this atrocity which occurred 200 years ago.  OF course, the Aboriginal community is still hurting from this and it is not just in a spiritual way, but in an actual physical way; but WHAT CAN WE DO? - And we are looking for an answer, not asking this facetiously to cause further hurt. 

Another issue which was raised and may not be politically correct, but is important nonetheless, is that we all felt that we had been over-exposed to the story of the White Settlers and the Aboriginals.  We have heard the stories so many times that we had become immune and uninterested in hearing the same stories over and over.  Given this, it was interesting that for some of us it was the first time we had heard the reality of the situation - is what we are being taught in school about Our History being taught in the most efficient and effective way?  We also discussed the series of events which led to this violence and background of the White Settlers which we felt was a really important factor in their actions - though not a justification of what they had done.  It is important to remember that these were generally people who had grown up in London, had lived small and hard lives, and then had been transported to the other side of the world for small, petty crimes.  They are not worldly people, they were not farmers, they were not educated - their actions seemed to be largely fuelled by fear, a desire to "make something" of themselves, and to protect their families. 

The story is a complex one: it left me with more questions than answers.  As the author said it happened on both sides, and on both sides it did not happen because these people were just bad or evil people, it happened because when you have a complete lack of understanding and you have two different sets of people needing the same resource (that is good riverside land), it's almost inevitable that you're going to have violence.  Unless the people involved have enormous insight and imagination, it's going to be quite hard to avoid violence.  But neither side were simply evil specimens of humanity.  I feel The Secret River is important in brining life and names and emotions to the story of White Settlement (Invasion?) in Australia - it is uncomfortable, challenging, disgusting, frustrating and shocking and so important that I would suggest that it could find and important place on the Year 12 HSC curriculum - though not if it risked further "over-exposing" this story.  It was lovely to finish off our London meeting with a Skype session with Lou in Sydney - although by that time inevitably - wine had been drunk, many tangents had been explored, and we were more interested in discussing tattoos that the book - but this again is the beauty of Book Club!


By Clare
(look her up on Facebook, she's hot)

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.