Angus & Robertson has recently released its latest Top 100 books list. They apparently received over 26000 votes for the poll – but I’d like to ask who these people actually were? I have seen a lot of these lists come out (and I have to say that I am a massive fan of the original Angus & Robertson Top 100 list) but this list to me just seems odd. Coming in at #4 is The Obernewtyn Chronciles – what the frig is that?!?! Harry Potter came in at #1 which was not much of a surprise, but Twilight at #2? Were most of the votes taken online? If so, I am hazarding a guess that the people voting on this poll are all part of whichever die hard online fandom applies to each of the above mentioned book series because there is NO WAY that the popular Australian vote would allocate these series the top spots (HP excepted). Maybe I’m wrong and I just don’t understand … the funny thing is that I went into my local Angus & Robertson this morning and the sales lady I spoke to had no idea what The Obernewtyn Chronicles were either. At any rate, for me the only saving grace was Pride and Prejudice coming in at #3 – and even with that one I am sceptical, I hope these voters are voting for the book and not the movie (but both are good).
My other gripe with this list are the double ups; there are 4 books apiece for Jodi Picoult and Matthew Reilly. Now, while I like all the books written by both of these authors – especially Matthew Reilly – they are all pretty much the same, or just as similar as the books in the Harry Potter series. Why bundle the Harry Potter Series and the Twilight Series into one and not Reillys “Scarecrow” books? Without sounding too book snobby, they are clogging these nice lists with too much pulp fiction. And I know I neglected to mention other authors who also feature multiple times like Bryce Courtenay (4 books) or Tim Winton (3 books) – so sue me! – I feel their books all stand alone from each other.
On a positive note, I was happy to see some of my favourite books on there: Memoirs of a Geisha (#16), A Thousand Splendid Suns (#29), The Alchemist (#57) and my most recent read We Need to Talk about Kevin (#91)
See the full list here

RSS Feed